Leadership performance review phrases
Leadership feedback should point to decisions and their effect on the team, not to traits like "strong presence" that nobody can act on. Below are 33 phrases sorted by rating, with self-evaluation versions, goals and a sample review you can adapt.
Lauren is a real coach. You're texting an AI trained on her coaching.
What good leadership looks like
Leadership in a review covers how someone sets direction, develops people and makes decisions, whether or not they manage anyone. Reviewers look for clarity, follow-through, and how the people around them perform and grow.
- Sets clear priorities and explains the why
- Develops people through feedback and stretch work
- Makes decisions with incomplete information
- Owns mistakes in public
- Has hard conversations instead of avoiding them
Exceeds expectations
For work that sets the standard. Add the specific result after each phrase; that's what makes it believable.
- Sets clear priorities and explains the reasoning, so the team makes good calls without escalating every decision.
- Developed [name] and [name] into leads this year through regular feedback and stretch assignments.
- Makes timely decisions with incomplete information and adjusts quickly when new facts arrive.
- Took ownership of [incident] in front of leadership and led the fix without assigning blame.
- Has hard conversations early, so performance issues on the team are addressed in weeks, not quarters.
- Kept the team focused through [change]; nobody on the team left during the reorg.
- Builds trust by doing what they say, so their team always knows where it stands.
- Advocates for the team's needs with leadership while staying aligned with company goals.
Meets expectations
For solid, reliable work. "Meets expectations" is a good rating, so say that out loud in the conversation too.
- Provides clear direction and sets reasonable expectations.
- Holds regular one-on-ones and gives useful feedback.
- Makes sound decisions and communicates them clearly.
- Delegates appropriately and follows up on progress.
- Supports team members' development.
- Addresses team problems as they come up.
- Represents the team well in cross-functional settings.
- Models the standards they expect from others.
Needs improvement
Pair each one with a specific example and a goal. A needs-improvement line without a next step reads as a verdict.
- Tends to make decisions alone and announce them, which leaves the team feeling excluded. Asking for input before deciding would build buy-in.
- Avoids hard conversations; [issue] went on for several months before it was addressed.
- Delegates tasks without the context people need, which leads to rework.
- Steps in to fix the team's work rather than coaching them through it, which limits their growth and the manager's time.
- Changes priorities often without explaining why, which makes it hard for the team to plan.
- Cancels one-on-ones frequently; the team would benefit from a steady rhythm.
- Saves feedback for review time; more frequent, informal feedback would help people adjust sooner.
- Hesitates to make calls when information is incomplete, which slows the team down.
Self-evaluation: strengths
First-person versions for your own review. Swap in your real projects and numbers.
- I held weekly one-on-ones with every direct report all year and never let one slip two weeks in a row.
- I promoted [name] to lead after a year of stretch assignments and regular feedback.
- I made the call on [decision] with incomplete data, and it saved us [result].
- I addressed [performance issue] within two weeks of noticing it, and the person is now on track.
- I kept the team informed through the reorg with weekly updates, and we didn't lose anyone.
Self-evaluation: where you're growing
Name the gap and what you're doing about it. Reviewers trust a self-evaluation that includes one honest growth area.
- I still jump in to fix work myself. I want to coach the team through problems instead.
- I've put off some hard conversations longer than I should have. I'm committing to address issues within two weeks.
- I need to explain the why behind priority changes, not just the change.
- I'd like to hand my team more of the work leadership sees, so they get that exposure.
Leadership goals for next period
Goals work when someone else could tell whether they happened.
- Hold weekly one-on-ones with every direct report, with a shared agenda.
- Delegate [project] fully to [name] by [date], checking in weekly instead of reviewing every step.
- Give each direct report one piece of specific feedback every two weeks, outside of review season.
A sample review paragraph
Behavior, example, impact, then one growth area with a goal. Replace the brackets with specifics from the review period.
[Name] sets clear direction and explains the reasoning, so the team makes good decisions on its own. This year they developed [name] into a lead and kept the team steady through the reorg with weekly updates. They own mistakes in public, which has built trust. One area to build on: they still step in to fix work rather than coaching the person through it. Next quarter, the goal is to fully delegate [project] to [name], with weekly check-ins.
How to say it in the review meeting
Leaders get less feedback than almost anyone, so make yours specific. Point to decisions and their effect on the team rather than traits.
If you're reviewing a new manager, separate skills they haven't learned yet from habits that need to change. And ask what support they need. A manager who's struggling is often missing context or backing, not ability.
Talk it through with Lauren
The written review is half the job. Here's what it looks like to get the hardest line right by text, the night before.
my new manager keeps doing her team's work for them. how do I put that in her review kindly
super common in year one. she's good at the work, so it feels faster to just do it
is there a recent example where it cost her or the team something?
she rewrote the Q3 deck at midnight instead of giving the analyst feedback
use that. "When you rewrote the Q3 deck yourself, [analyst] lost the chance to learn and you lost a night. Next time: give feedback and let them make the changes." frame it as the next skill, not a failure
Get a second read before you send it.
Text Lauren the situation and your draft. She'll help you make it specific and fair, and prep you for the conversation itself.
Hi Lauren! I'm writing a performance review and want help with the leadership section.
Lauren is a real coach. You're texting an AI trained on her coaching. Your first week is free. Cancel anytime from your account or by texting Lauren.
Frequently asked questions
How do you review leadership for someone who doesn't manage people?
Look at influence without authority: setting direction on a project, mentoring peers, owning a problem nobody else wanted, and making decisions others follow. That's leadership too.
What are good leadership goals for a performance review?
Habits you can see: weekly one-on-ones held, a project fully delegated, feedback given every two weeks, a successor developed. Avoid goals like "be more strategic" that nobody can measure.
How do I give leadership feedback to my own boss?
Usually in an upward review or a skip-level, framed around the effect on your work: "When priorities change without the reason, it's hard for us to plan. Knowing the why would help." Specific and forward-looking works best.